FAQ
35 answered questions17 official
Rules questions from the BoardGameGeek forum. Answers marked Official were confirmed by Splotter Spellen or the designers; official accounts: jmdsplotter.
Common mistakes
Showing 35 of 35
Can I flip a building tile to fit it into my city? Official
No. Rotate tiles as needed, but do not flip them. The designer confirmed the answer alongside the Fishery pollution clarification.
Source: BGG Rules forum
May a Hospital clear open city squares before clearing buildings? Official
Yes. You may remove graves from open city squares while leaving graves on buildings. The placement rule does not force the reverse order when removing graves.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can Theology raze and rebuild a Cathedral in the same turn? Official
Yes. You may build the new Cathedral during the same City Building phase. The usual costs still apply; a Cathedral with graves, or one dedicated to Santa Maria, cannot be razed.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can Santa Barbara move buildings between my cities? Official
Yes. Her rearrangement ability can move buildings between your city grids, not only within their original grid.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can Santa Barbara merge or reshape my Stores? Official
No. Separate Stores cannot be merged. Once a Store’s rectangular shape is chosen, that shape stays fixed.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can I move a grave-covered building together with its graves?
The linked community answer permits moving it with its existing graves, referring to an older ruling. Do not use rearrangement to put additional graves onto a building. The ordinary rule still allows moving graves to empty city squares.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does a grave-covered Cathedral prevent Theology from razing it?
Yes. The rulebook explicitly forbids razing a Cathedral containing graves; the forum question points back to that restriction.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Are Cart Shops a shared supply or a personal four-tile limit? Official
They are a shared supply until exhausted, not four reserved copies per player. The printed quantities differ between editions; use the supply of the edition being played. The designer’s answer confirms the shared-pool rule.
Source: BGG Rules forum
What are the coloured square counters in the third edition? Official
They are alternative Inn counters. They represent the same Inns as the wooden pieces, not extra buildings or an additional action.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can the last player choose any starting tile?
Yes. Choose in reverse initial turn order from any still-available lettered starting tile, not a tile predetermined by your seat. The starting city must fit fully on that one tile.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does apparent mixed terrain on a landscape hex let me choose its type?
No. The linked community discussion identifies the pictured marks as printing bleed rather than a dual-terrain rule. Use the intended single terrain; compare the physical map where a boundary is unclear.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Do I need a Harbour to build a Fishery? Official
No. A Harbour is unnecessary when the Fishery’s land hexes already meet the reach requirement. Both land hexes must touch unpolluted water and at least one must be in your zone.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Where does a Fishery’s worker go? Official
On the two-hex Fishery building, not on a sea resource. It stays there until the Fishery is exhausted.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can one Fishery produce different goods from separate lakes? Official
No. One Fishery produces a single chosen good across all the unpolluted water hexes it uses, even if those hexes belong to separate lakes. Another Fishery may choose another good.
Source: BGG Rules forum
May a Farm use grass that still holds a Woodcutter’s wood? Official
No. A hex can hold only one good awaiting harvest. The grass is not available to a new Farm while that wood remains.
Source: BGG Rules forum
What happens to pollution underneath a Fishery? Official
Leave it underneath. A Fishery may stand on polluted shore; removing the exhausted tile exposes that pollution again. Inns and cities, which are permanent, use their own placement rules.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can I leave an exploration marker instead of putting a producer’s resource there? Official
No. Fill all eligible production hexes. Remove an exploration marker covered by the production without looking at it.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does Biology replace the Cart Shop worker?
No. Staff Biology, or its connected University, and a Cart Shop separately. Biology waives the seed for one Farm; the worker from the Cart Shop goes to the Farm.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can both Fishery hexes touch the same remaining unpolluted sea hex?
Yes. Both shore hexes must touch at least one unpolluted sea hex, and it may be the same hex. The ordinary reach and occupation requirements still apply.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Is an exhausted Fishery removed?
Yes. Remove it during Harvest and return it to the shared supply when all its resources are gone. Its worker returns too.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can a Harbour let me build a city on water?
No. A Harbour extends reach; it does not change a building’s allowed terrain. Later cities occupy land only, and producers retain their terrain requirements.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can my reach pass through an opponent’s city?
The linked community answers treat city hexes as not blocking reach; count land distance normally. Water still blocks ordinary land reach.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does a mountain range keep its first chosen resource?
Yes. The first Mine fixes stone or gold for the whole connected range. Dividing it visually with a city does not reset that choice. A reminder beside the map is a practical aid, not an extra game action.
Source: BGG Rules forum
May the Market obtain a seed that has not been discovered?
Yes. Trading any two goods to the supply gives any one good, including a seed nobody has explored or produced yet.
Source: BGG Rules forum
How many trades can a staffed Market make?
There is no one-trade-per-turn limit. During City Building, make as many trades as you can pay for; the two goods paid to the supply may differ.
Source: BGG Rules forum
May a player give goods away in a Market trade? Official
Yes. The designer allows a gift through player-to-player trading. At least one participant still needs a staffed Market.
Source: BGG Rules forum
May I choose different goods to store from those stored last round?
Yes. Phase 5 is the storage check. Choose the goods you retain then, using current staffed capacity. Outside that check your goods can be used regardless of which pile they were in.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Do goods disappear immediately if I stop staffing their Store?
No. Use them normally before the next Store Goods check. Any surplus lacking staffed capacity is discarded in phase 5, before new Harvest.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Can a player with no wood and no Woodcutter recover?
An opponent with a staffed Market may trade or give wood. Without that cooperation or another way to obtain wood, your own engine may be unable to restart. Preserve wood access rather than relying on a rescue.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does Santa Barbara need buildings free of graves? Official
Yes. You need one functional, grave-free example of every city-building type. Extra copies of a repeated building may contain graves; you do not need every copy clear.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does San Christofori really require 24 goods? Official
Yes: three each of grain, olives, sheep, fish, wine, dye, pearls and gold. Wood and stone are not part of the requirement.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Does San Giorgio need to surround every opponent?
No. The rulebook requires the whole zone of control of any one other player to lie in yours. The linked thread discusses an online result; that implementation dispute is not an additional tabletop rule.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Do I spend food during Famine?
No. Food ownership reduces famine graves without discarding that food. Granary protects its owner, while a Fountain lowers the shared Famine Level once when built.
Source: BGG Rules forum
May Alchemy clear beneath occupied production hexes?
The linked community rules summary treats resources and Fishery buildings as blocking access to the underlying pollution. It does not provide a new designer ruling. Keep active goods and buildings in place; do not use Alchemy to remove them.
Source: BGG Rules forum
Is a C missing from the third-edition reach diagram? Official
The designer confirms a missing C in the illustrated third-edition example. Use the written reach rules. For the Woodcutter size-two example, either the top or bottom B hex works.
Source: BGG Rules forum