Lawsuits and Courts
Water, commercial, criminal and rights cases, how the Count decides them, player courts and tax credit markers.
Lawsuits
In the full game, lawsuits start automatically: when the trigger happens, the case is filed, and nobody can choose to drop it. Each case has its own lawsuit markers. One marker joins the queue of whoever will decide the case, entering at the bottom and pushing older cases up. Other markers show where the case is and who is involved. The back of your family board lists every trigger.
Water cases
Filed when anyone changes the water state of your claim: dry to wet, or wet to dry. Flooding by a peat digger and draining by a windmill both count. Each affected plot gets a location marker.
Commercial cases
Filed when a village buys a good from a producer that isn’t the largest producer of that good. The largest producer sues the village. “Largest” means strictly more; a tie gives no case.
Criminal cases
Filed when a village bought the last good of a type, and a later village that wanted that good finds none. The village that bought it takes a defence marker on its for-sale marker.
Rights cases
Filed when someone has more cubes contributing to a producer’s production than its owner. That player claims the producer belongs to them. If the claim is granted:
- the claimant takes over the building and its charter, with everything on it;
- the old owner loses one cube from the map and gets one coin on their family board as compensation.
This is the only way to lose cubes from the map, and the compensation coin can make it worthwhile.
How the Count decides
At the start of each round except the first, the Count decides every case in his queue except the newest ones: as many stay waiting as the tax level. A case can stay waiting for several rounds, or never be decided.
| Case | The Count’s ruling |
|---|---|
| Water | Each plot with a location marker goes back to its previous state |
| Commercial | If the producer that sued still has goods in stock, it wins 1 coin for every 2 goods still in stock and keeps those goods. If it has none left, the village wins a tax credit marker |
| Criminal | If the defence marker is still there (no new goods of that type came in), the accused village is guilty: the other village gets a tax credit marker. Otherwise the accused village gets it. The winner may also swap its village’s turn-order tile with another of its own tiles |
| Rights | Follows the board as it stands now. A tie goes to the defendant |
Player courts
You can start a court of your own. Like a polder boss, a court starts on a plot adjacent to a started village, and each village can have at most one court next to it. There are courts for water, commercial and rights cases, each with two versions:
| Court | Version A | Version B |
|---|---|---|
| Water | Always rules dry | Always rules wet |
| Commercial | The producer gets 1 coin per good left | The producer gets 1 coin per full set of 3 goods left |
| Rights | Ties go to the defendant | Ties go to the claimant |
The first family to start a water court picks which version; the second one gets the version left. A court’s version never changes.
- When started: the court takes the oldest case of its type from the Count’s queue.
- New cases of its type go to the court instead of the Count. With two courts of a type, the case goes to the court closer to it.
- One case at a time: when a new case arrives, the case it was holding goes to the bottom of the Count’s queue.
- Every case taken pays the court 1 coin. On its turn the court spends its coins to expand colour-adjacent, like a village. A court boxed in by other cubes can’t use its coins.
Tax credit markers
Tax credit markers go on a village. On its turn, each marker it uses lowers its demand as if the tax level were one step lower; two markers lower it two steps. The village still expands by the actual tax level. Unused markers are discarded at the end of the village’s turn.